As of December 31, 2014, I retired from full-time teaching in Humboldt State University's Department of History. While this website will remain online, it is no longer maintained.

History 110 - Dr. Gayle Olson-Raymer

Colonial Discontent

Map of 13 colonies

Today we leave our first unit of study - Intrusions into an Old World and the Beginnings of a "New World" - during which we learned about why Europeans settled in north America, the colonial patterns of settlement in the New England, Middle, and Southern colonies, the Indian nations removed from the areas of Euro-American settlement, and the conditions under which Africans were kidnapped from Africa and forced into slavery in the "New World."

The second unit of study in our story - Foundations of a New Nation and Experiments with Freedom - begins with an understanding of how the North America colonists gradually begin to think of themselves as different from and eventually as independent from their colonial rulers in England. This unit, then, shapes the story of how and why the colonists decided to proclaim their independence, entered into and won a war with England, and began a new nation.

Our first discussion in this new unit focuses on colonial discontent - the rising awareness of the colonists that only a few among them were becoming very wealthy while the majority were not getting what they believed was their share of colonial wealth.

Discussion Goals: Colonial Discontent

  1. To get a glimpse of life in the colonies in 1775, the year before the colonists claimed their independence from Britain.
  2. To discuss wealth distribution in colonial America.
  3. To discuss the changes in colonial society in the 18th century.
  4. To examine the changing economic characteristics in 18th century colonial America.
  5. To demonstrate how such changes, combined with the growing divisions among the colonists and between the colonies, led to a great deal of discontent and divisiveness.
  6. To illustrate that despite such discontent and disunity,  the colonists were able to unite under the banner of several shared characteristics and beliefs in order to defeat the British.
  7. To understand contemporary wealth distribution in America and compare it with wealth distribution in colonial America.

Goal #1: To get a glimpse of life in the colonies in 1775, the year before the colonists claimed their independence from Britain


Goal #2: To discuss wealth distribution in colonial 18th century America

How was wealth measured in colonial America? By land ownership! And who were these colonists who owned land just prior to the American Revolution?

How was wealth distributed in colonial America. We only have a few cities with statistics, Boston being one of these.

This graph demonstrates that throughout much of the colonial period:

In short, for the top 10%, the percentage of wealth steadily increased throughout the colonial period while for the remaining 90% of the colonists, the percentage of wealth steadily decreased.

Map of comparitive wealth distribution in colonial Boston and PhiladelphiaWe can see this trend more clearly with these comparison statistics from Boston, Philadelphia, and Chester County, Pennsylvania.

So, if the rich were getting richer and the poor were getting poorer in colonial North America, we can see that colonial society was quite unequal. In fact, the term equality - which the colonists began to liberally use during the pre-revolutionary period - had a very different meaning in the 1700s.

 


Goal #3: To discuss the changes in colonial society in the 18th century

Throughout the 18th Century, the colonies were becoming more diverse as their populations expanded. In fact, the population doubled every generation, largely because of high fertility, increased immigration, and lower mortality rates:

It is important to remember that the colonies remained primarily English; thus, most of the colonists continued to think of themselves as Englishmen and women - as subjects of the British Empire. This began to change in the early 1800s. after North Americans won their freedom from England and when more immigrants were non-English - primarily German and Scots-Irish.

Except for large parts of Virginia and South Carolina, the colonial population was primarily white, European, and Protestant. Most Indians had been pushed into areas of non-white settlement. Only a few Jews and Catholics arrived during this period. (To see a great timeline of the history of religion in America from colonial times to the present, go to http://atheism.about.com/library/FAQs/religion/blrel_amrel_chron.htm

By 1790 during the first Federal Census, less than half of Americans were English in origin; approximately 20% were African; 15% were Scot or Irish; 7% were German; and the remainder were of other ethnic backgrounds.

Map of immigration to U.S. in 1700s

chart of religious diversity in colonial america in 1750

 


Goal #4: To examine the changing economic characteristics in 18th century colonial America

Graph of economic growth in U.S. from 1700-1850

1. Economic growth dramatically increased, giving British colonists a higher standard of living than their European counterparts.  In general, colonists engaged in four types of work:

2. Capitalist enterprise grew, diversified, and became more specialized, leading to the growth of three colonial capitalist classes: 3. Land purchase and allotment became more speculative and profit-motivated.  From the 1700s forward, land in all the colonies was increasingly sold for profit and speculation rather than small settlement.  By 1720, so much land had been taken up by speculation in all colonies that a poor man who did not have money was forced to "squat" on Crown or proprietary land and repeat the process if he were forced to move on.

Goal #5: To demonstrate how such changes, combined with the growing divisions among the colonists and between the colonies, led to a great deal of discontent and divisiveness.

Discontent and division among the colonists and between the colonies was common by the mid-1700s. The colonists had never been a homogeneous lot of people who looked, thought, acted, worshiped, or worked alike. There were differences and divisions among them from the very beginning.


Goal #6: To illustrate that despite such discontent and disunity, the colonists were able to unite under the banner of several shared characteristics and beliefs in order to defeat the British

Common beliefs of the majority of the population:

According to revisionist historians, such characteristics and beliefs temporarily bound many colonists together.  They argue that many colonists temporarily united largely because of their desire to destroy a common enemy - not because they were a united people. And who were those who did not choose to join the cause of independence - the substantial minority who did not join the War effort but remained Loyalists?


Goal #7: To understand contemporary wealth distribution in America and compare it with wealth distribution in colonial America

You should have all gained an understanding of the contemporary income inequality in the U.S. after watching Inequality for All and listening to the podcast "Upward Mobility". Now, let's look at this map derived from CIA statistics that illustrates how our wealth distribution compares with other nations:

Map of world's wealth distribution

Blue countries are more equal than the U.S., red countries are less equal. The above map gives you a sense of just how severe economic inequality is in the United States; much higher than in any other developed country, and most developing countries as well.

2013 Map of Upward Mobility in U.S.

The following summarizes and provides excerpts from the findings of Sociologist Dr. William Dumhoff at UC Santa Cruz in his website Who Rules America at http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/wealth.html:

Graph of 2010 net wealth of Americans

According to Dr. Dumhoff, "In terms of types of financial wealth, the top one percent of households have 35% of all privately held stock, 64.4% of financial securities, and 62.4% of business equity. The top ten percent have 81% to 94% of stocks, bonds, trust funds, and business equity, and almost 80% of non-home real estate. Since financial wealth is what counts as far as the control of income-producing assets, we can say that just 10% of the people own the United States of America."

Was this trend typical of most of the 20th Century?

And who have been the wealthiest men in U.S. history? As the New York Times survey indicates, John D. Rockefeller (1839-1937) - the wealthiest American to ever live - was an oil tycoon worth $900 million when he died - a sum worth $192 billion in 2010.

Discussion:

Sources:

 


Conclusions - Colonial Discontent

  1. Colonial society was quite unequal in terms of our modern understanding of equality.
  2. The term equality - which the colonists began to liberally use during the revolutionary period - had a very different meaning in the 1700s. Equality meant that no man held greater rights by birth than any other man. When the colonists called for equality, they meant to undue to British practice of hereditary privilege. What they really believed is that all men were created equal and should have an equal opportunity to earn social privilege.
  3. Americans have always witnessed deep divisions in wealth distribution.  Figures from the colonial cities of Boston, Philadelphia, and New York indicate that at the end of the 17th Century, the top ten percent of wealthiest citizens owned about 46% of all the wealth in all three cities.  By the end of the 18th Century in Boston and Philadelphia, the top ten percent owned 63.4% and 65.7% of all the wealth respectively, while in New York, the top ten percent owned about 3% less wealth than it had in the previous century. 
  4. The nature of colonial America's society, population, and economy gradually changed throughout the 1700s. Such changes brought about social, economic, and political divisions among the colonists and between the colonies.
  5. Given the extraordinarily diverse makeup of American society and and the growing divisions among many colonists and between the colonies, it is amazing that by the mid-17th century, many English colonists were able to unite to declare independence and create a new nation.
  6. Yet, despite their divisions, the colonists shared enough common beliefs and traits to overcome their disagreements and fight the British.
  7. Throughout most of the 18th Century, the colonists continued to think of themselves as Englishmen and women, or subjects of the British Empire.  Only when they stopped thinking of themselves as English and began thinking of themselves as distinctly American - with political, economic, and social goals and needs that were different from those of the English - did a significant number of colonial leaders seek permanent political independence from England.